If you watch Man v. Food then you’ve heard of Big Pie In The Sky (it was featured in one of the earlier episodes). It’s known for The Carnivore Challenge (you and a friend must eat an 11 pound pizza consisting of pepperoni, ground beef, Italian sausage, ham and bacon in under an hour and you win $250).
The challenges are only available Monday through Thursday at 3:30 and 8:30 p.m. and Sundays at 3:30 p.m. We did not order the Carnivore (we weren’t here on the right day) although my friend did claim he wanted to. Even though it was raining the place was busy and there was a bit of a wait. We decide to go ahead and order the XL 30″ (Half Cheese/Half Carnivore) and I tack on a meatball and chicken parmesan sub as our future table clears up. Their catchphrase is right, their slices are literally bigger than your head.
As we dig in, I decide to sample the 2 subs. Both subs were lackluster. The meatballs didn’t really have too much flavor and the chicken parmesan, well there is no way it was fresh. It had to be frozen.
Once my friends got around to trying the subs they agreed with me. On the flip side, the pizza was amazing. We all agreed that this is definitely a good pizza with a great crust. Now the real question is, could my friend have completed The Carnivore Challenge? Doubtful.
Big Pie In The Sky Pizzeria
2090 Baker Rd NW # 103
Kennesaw, GA 30144-4601