Cathy O’Clarke’s In Marco Island, Florida – CLOSED

Cathy O' Clarke's Cobblestone

An Irish Pub in Marco Island? That’s what I thought when I found out about it. It’s the sister restaurant of Almost Famous Mel’s (now closed) which is located about a block away (Mel & Cathy are married). Marcela and I are looking over the menu with my parents. A couple of things catch my eye on their menu (three is more than a couple but you get the drift): Onion Rings, Mozzarella Sticks and the Wexford Wings. The Onion Rings were not freshly made and that quickly diminished the likelihood of loving them, they were passable.

Onion Rings

Onion Rings

The Mozzarella Sticks were pretty stupendous. Chunks of Mozzarella breaded and fried, uh hello…awesome.

Cheese Sticks

Mozzarella Sticks

I have no words to describe the Wexford Wings (well actually I guess I do). Their menu says the Wexford Wings are prepared via a three step process. Whatever that process maybe, these little dudes were way good. The sauce on them was really unlike anything I’ve had on wings (maybe I’m stretching) and they had a flavor reminiscent of what you’d find in the chinese dish General Tso’s Chicken.

Wexford Wings

Wexford Wings

Marcela didn’t order an entree but I did (which means she did). My mother had the Fish & Chips & my father ordered the Philly Cheesesteak. The Fish & Chips and the Cheesesteak were nothing special.

Fish & Chips

Fish & Chips

Cheesesteak

Cheesesteak

I went with…..wait for it….the Cheeseburger. The real fail was the Burger and Fries. The Fries were the kind that have that crispy coating exterior (never liked these and I wonder where that texture comes from). The Burger was not a fresh patty. It was an ok kind of affair.

CheeseBurger

CheeseBurger

The menu mentioned Cheddar Cheese & I received Provolone. I like Provolone but it would have been nice to have known about the change. Too bad about the burger because Almost Famous Mel’s (now closed) Burger blows it away.

Cathy O’ Clarke’s is CLOSED
591 S. Collier Blvd, Marco Island, FL

239-642-9709

Cathy O'Clarke's Irish Pub on Urbanspoon

  • Gregg

    I would check the burgers out again you
    must have had a impact fresh burgers
    I am a fan of McFly’s Burger