Jimmy P’s Burgers – Naples, Florida

After the excellent experience at Jimmy P’s Charred, it was a no brainer that Jimmy P’s Burgers would be my next stop. I allowed all of about 24 hours to pass when I made the visit.

It took one glance at the menu to know there were more than a few dishes that I needed to try. So let’s see here….maybe the Chili, a Cheeseburger, wait…there’s homemade Pastrami? Ok, then a Pastrami Sandwich and a Hot Dog to wash everything down. I was tempted to add Tacos of the Day to find what exactly the Market Price is but I had already overstepped my stomach boundaries.

The Chili was very meaty and exactly what I needed to get my motors running. They get extra points for serving it with Oyster Crackers. Before you even think it, I did not even try the Fries, Cole Slaw or bag of Chips. I took them back to the lair I was staying at in Naples with my family.

The Wagyu Dog had some grill marks which equal extra flavor in my book. I slathered some Yellow Mustard on it and was good to go. The Pastrami Sandwich comes with Swiss Cheese which I didn’t mind at all. I’m not a Pastrami Sandwich purist plus Swiss is one of my favorites cheeses so you won’t get any complaints from me. Now that was a great sandwich.

The 8 oz. CheeseBurger was ground in-house and served Medium which has all the beginnings of a true burger love story. The bun looks abnormally large in the picture but I don’t remember thinking that when I was eating it so maybe it was an optical illusion. There’s a Jalapeño Burger with a Jalapeño spiced beef patty and Pepper Jack Cheese as one of their pre-set burger selections. I’m kicking myself for not trying it. There was also a Swiss Burger with Caramelized Onions, Swiss Cheese and a “Burger Sauce” on Marble Rye. I’m gonna go out on a limb and say this is their version of a Patty Melt. Again, another fella I should have tried.

In case you haven’t noticed, I’m trying to build a solid case in my head to return to Jimmy P’s Burgers. Well, it’s definitely happening sooner than later.

Menu Page 1 (click to enlarge)

Menu Page 2 (click to enlarge)


Wagyu Cheeseburger

Homemade Pastrami Sandwich & Slaw

Homemade Pastrami Sandwich & Slaw

Wagyu Hot Dog

Jimmy P’s Burgers
1201 Piper Blvd #11
Naples, FL 34110