Jimmy P’s Burgers in Naples, Florida

El Rey de las Fritas 468 x 60 Banner

After the excellent experience at Jimmy P’s Charred, it was a no-brainer that Jimmy P’s Burgers (1201 Piper Blvd #11, Naples) would be my next stop. I allowed all of about 24 hours to pass when I visited.

Jimmy P's Burgers Menu from Naples, Florida
Menu Front Page
Jimmy P's Burgers Menu Back from Naples, Florida
Menu Back

It took one glance at the menu to know there were more than a few dishes that I needed to try. So let’s see here, maybe the chili, a cheeseburger, and wait, there’s homemade pastrami?

Ok, then a pastrami sandwich and a hot dog to wash everything down. I was tempted to add tacos of the day to find what exactly the market price is, but I had already overstepped my stomach boundaries.

Jimmy P's Burgers Chili in Naples, Florida

The chili was very meaty and precisely what I needed to get my motors running. Of course, they get extra points for serving it with oyster crackers.

Before you even think it, I did not try the fries, coleslaw, or bag of chips. Instead, I took them back to the lair I was staying at in Marco Island with my family.

Wagyu Kobe Hot Dog from Jimmy P's Burgers in Naples, Florida
Wagyu Kobe Hot Dog

The wagyu dog had some grill marks, which equal extra flavor in my book. I slathered some yellow mustard on it and was good to go.

Jimmy P’s Pastrami Talk

Homemade Pastrami Sandwich from Jimmy P's Burgers in Naples, Florida
Homemade Pastrami Sandwich w/Coleslaw

The pastrami sandwich comes with swiss cheese, which I didn’t mind at all. I’m not a pastrami sandwich purist, plus Swiss is one of my favorite cheeses. So you won’t get any complaints from me.

Now that was a great sandwich.

The eight oz. cheeseburger was ground in-house and served medium, which has all the beginnings of a real burger love story. The bun looks abnormally large in the picture, but I don’t remember thinking that when I was eating it, so maybe it was an optical illusion.

Wagyu Cheeseburger from Jimmy P's Burgers in Naples, Florida
Wagyu Cheeseburger

One of their pre-set burger selections is a jalapeño burger with a jalapeño spiced beef patty and pepper jack cheese. I’m kicking myself for not trying it.

There was also a Swiss burger with caramelized onions, Swiss cheese, and a burger sauce on marble rye bread. I’m going to go out on a limb and say this is their version of a patty melt. Yet again, another fellow I should have tried.

If you haven’t noticed, I’m trying to build a solid case in my head to return to Jimmy P’s Burgers. Well, it’s happening sooner than later.

Leave a Comment