Magic City Pizza

Magic City Pizza had the unenviable task of opening up in the same spot where my beloved That Pizza Place on Coral Way (R.I.P.) was. That essentially means that I would have a certain level of expectation even though I know they’re not the same owners.

Yes, I know….how yelpie of me.

On my first visit to Magic City Pizza (7401 Coral Way), I started with just a pepperoni pie and some garlic rolls. The pizza, while slightly undercooked, was good (the rolls were perfect), but what was missing was the pepperoni portion of it with about an average of 3 small ones per slice, not a good start or ratio.

They had just recently opened at this point. I’m well aware that sometimes it takes time to work out the kinks, learn how to use your oven, and find your groove.

When I returned a few short weeks later, I hoped for the best, and my expectations were exceeded. The garlic rolls game, which was already very good, had been stepped up, but now the pizza was also on point.

Currently, I’m crushing on the White Pizza (ricotta, mozzarella, parmesan, olive oil & oregano), and you definitely can’t miss with the pepperoni, now with those little pepperoni cups.

While we’re on the topic of must-haves, add the wings and Abuela’s homemade flan. Yes, there’s flan at Magic City Pizza, and it’s no joke.

What’s your go-to at a pizza joint?

Magic City Pizza Menu

Menu P1
Magic City Pizza Menu P1
Magic City Pizza Menu P2
Menu P2

Magic City Pizza Food Pictures

Magic City Pizza Garlic Rolls
Magic City Pizza Garlic Rolls
Sweet Sriracha Wings
Buffalo Wings
Garlic Parm Wings
Garlic Parm Fries
Chicken Parm Sub
Chicken Parm Sub
Magic City Pizza Meatball Sub
Magic City Pizza Meatball Sub
Ziti with Meatballs
Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken
Pepperoni Pizza
Meat Lovers Pizza
White Pizza
Rice Pudding

Magic City Pizza Accolades

2017 Burger Beast Burgie Awards for Best Garlic Rolls

2018 Best Flan at Flantastic!


  1. Went to Magic City off your recommendation on your instagram and was very impressed. You also have to try the Alfredo Pasta with the crispy chicken (instead of the grilled chicken) very good. Also the meat lovers pie was on point.

Comment Away!