Sami’s Pizza & Grill in Marco Island, Florida

Years back, I had stopped into Sami’s Pizza & Grill (227 N Collier Boulevard) when it was Sami’s Kwik Stop, a convenience store that was just starting to sell pizza. I didn’t think much of it then when I dropped in to get some colas, nor did I realize they would be expanding to a full-fledged restaurant.

My parents and I are driving up and down Marco Island’s main drag when the sign for Sami’s catches my eye. They weren’t too keen on stopping in since the restaurant space was under construction.

Everything was boarded up including the entrance through the dimly lit back area. It was hard-selling them on going in, after which they finally caved in begrudgingly. It’s a good thing cause it was worth all the hassle.

Sami's Pizza & Grill Lunch Menu
Sami’s Pizza & Grill Lunch Menu Page 1
Lunch Menu Page 2 from Sami's Pizza & Grill in Marco Island, Florida
Lunch Menu Page 2

Download the Lunch Menu .PDF or the Dinner Menu .PDF

So, What’d We Eat?

The menu has the usual pizza stuff with some burgers, kebabs, gyros, and *Mexican Food thrown in for good measure.

We did not try the kebabs or gyros but based on everything else we ate. It seems like it would be a safe bet that they’re good. The garlic cheese bread was nice & toasty, garlicky, and a great way to start the meal.

Anytime I can eat a housemade tamale, count me in, and this one was no exception. I took a few to go so my wife could enjoy them also.

The wings are right on; this is exactly what you’re hoping for when you order Buffalo Wings. These fellas did not disappoint.

The cheese fries were just that, nothing more. They could use some livening up, maybe some proprietary seasoning or chopped bacon but not bad.

The tortilla chips were freshly made and served with salsa. No complaints from us; we scarfed them down.

The cheeseBurger didn’t do it for me. Let’s leave it at that.

Now, the pizza……WOW!!! This is the BEST Pizza I’ve eaten on Marco Island. We absolutely loved it, and so I added them to the “must eat from every time we’re in Marco Island list,“ you should too.

All in all, a great experience at a spot my parents were refusing to stop at. Good thing I stopped listening to them when I was 18, not really.

Sami’s Pizza & Grill Food Pics

Garlic Cheese Bread
Garlic Cheese Bread
Tamales with Rice and Refried Beans
Tamales with Rice and Refried Beans
Chicken Wings tossed in Buffalo sauce from Sami's Pizza & Grill in Marco Island, Florida
Chicken Wings tossed in Buffalo sauce
Cheese Fries
Cheese Fries
Tortilla Chips & Salsa
Tortilla Chips & Salsa
CheeseBurger with Fries
CheeseBurger with Fries
Pepperoni Pizza from Sami's Pizza & Grill in Marco Island, Florida
Pepperoni Pizza

*When I was updating the menus on this post I realized that all of the Mexican food had been removed.

Mignonette Ad sized 468 x 60

Leave a Comment