If you’ve followed my blog over the last 12 years, then you’ll know that I frequently write about what Chef Jeremiah Bullfrog is working on. My first encounter with his cuisine was at Art Basel in 2009, where he kickstarted the food truck revolution in South Florida with his gastroPod.
More recently, he had a series on HULU entitled Jeremiah Bullfrog Forks It.
A few years back, he did some Detroit-style pizza popups with his Square Pie City brand, which he resuscitated last year. Marcela and I drove out to Babe’s Meat & Counter in June to finally get our mitts on his pies.
Babe’s Meat & Counter and Boxelder (R.I.P.) are the two locations where he’s been consistently doing the pop-ups.
Since then, Square Pie City now has a permanent home in the Miami Design District in the old Pizza Volante & Harry’s Pizzeria space.
Square Pie City
3918 N Miami Ave
Miami, FL
(786) 408-3591
Website – https://www.squarepiecity.com
Instagram – https://www.instagram.com/squarepiecity
Monday CLOSED
Tuesday 12 pm – 3 pm, 5 pm – 9 pm
Wednesday 12 pm – 3 pm, 5 pm – 9 pm
Thursday 12 pm – 3 pm, 5 pm – 9 pm
Friday 11 am – 12 am
Saturday 11 am – 12 am
Sunday 12 pm – 12 am
Ordering Details & Suggestions
So after you’ve placed your order online, you have the option to pick up your food either Cold (reheat under a broiler) or Hot (eat in your car). I’m gonna go ahead and suggest you order everything hot.
The wings and meatballs are not always available. If they are, I sure do love those wangs.
The meatballs need to find a home in a sub of some sort, although I’m pretty sure I saw a meatball pie one week on the menu. Now that I think about it, I may have dreamed that. If that’s the case, it was a great one.
Marcela and I always have a hard time deciding what pizza to get, so it’s nice that the pies are available in full and half sizes. She chooses one half, and I choose another half; it works out well for both of us.
Normally, I’m a pepperoni pizza kinda fella, but the Red in the Head, Fire in the Bed makes me all kinds of crazy, and I blame the Calabrian chili oil. It’s also the one pie we both agree on.
I really dug the white pie last time I was there, and now I’ve got that magical mushroom in my sight. Unless, of course, that mysterious meatball pie rears its beautiful head again.
Square Pie City Menu
Square Pie City Starters
Hot Wangs
$10.00
Shaanxi Chicken Wings, Sichuan Peppercorns, Chili Oil
MeatBall(er)
$9.50
Pork, Veal & Mortadella meatballs cooked in dat sauce. (3) to a portion.
*contains garlic, cheese, pork, beef, gluten, and lots of love
Square Pie City Pizzas
Detroit Style Pizza Classix
$14.00 – $23.00
The original don dada PIE! Crispy cheese frico crust. Oozing mozzarella. Olive oil. Sauce top
This is the Square pizza that started it all.
(a full pie can feed 3 people or 2 with leftovers)
Half Pie is 8 x 10 and good individual option
Red in the Head, Fire in the Bed
$14.00 – $23.00
Detroit Style Pizza
Spicy PIE! Calabrian chili oil, mozz, dat red sauce
ILL Peps & Roni Cups
$16.00 – $25.00
The quintessential Pepperoni Pizza experience 🍕
Square Pie pizza now with 100% more meat (pork)
It’s That All White Err’ythang Pie
$15.00 – $25.00
Introducing the Detroit Style White Pizza! Housemade ricotta, roasted garlic sauce, Sicilian oregano, Provolone, Mozzerella, and Parmesan. It’s everything you have ever wanted in pizza.
Fathead Pizza (almond flour crust)
$16.00 – $29.00
Low carb Square PIE! Our signature style now Keto and Low carb friendly. Dat sauce, and whole milk mozzarella round out this bad boy.
Grandma PIE
$14.00 – $23.00
*For pizza lovers who prefer no crispy edges
Our Grandma Pizza’s are the same Square pie deliciousness for the younger or older crowd. Both Grandmother’s and children alike love our grandma pies! Order one now to please your picky pizza people.
Many Magical Mushrooms PIE
$15.00 – $25.00
Our crack team of foragers scour the earth to find the most magical of mushrooms which are treated to a patent (pending) process to transcend the humble fungus into the Many Magical Mushrooms PIE.
This white pie is finished with Asiago cheese, Provolone, and Mozz.
MEAT LOVAH PIE | BACON, SAUSAGE, & PEPPERONI!!!
$17.00 – $28.00
Meat Lovers Pie
WE DONE DID IT AGAIN! This 3 lb behemoth pie is sure to induce nap making and taking a necessity. Our Classix Detroit Style Pizza topped with all of our meats. Babe’s Bacon, pork fennel sausage crumbles and Smoked pepperoni cups.
Mel.Guez
$15.00 – $25.00
The Ultimate Sausage & Peppers Pie!
This pizza features Babe Froman’s merguez lamb sausage crumbles, charred peppers, and chopped broccoli rabe. The ultimate sausage pizza crust is cooked in butter!
*mild fennel pork sausage available as well
Da Green Supreme
$15.00 – $28.00
Da Green Supreme aka Veggie Pie is everything you ever wanted in a vegetarian pizza 🌱 This Detroit Style pie is topped with mushrooms, roasted mini peppers, chopped broccoli rabe, and kale pesto #greensupreme
* Vegan option is available
* Red sauce available as an option
This that Cali Green Pie
$14.00 – $23.00
Our Green Pie series, this one featuring Kale pesto, lemon zest, and Pecorino. Shown here on our Gluten free crust (still R&D) this pizza is the everyday eater. Super light and crisp, the combo of herbaceous green sauce and hit of lemon keeps you going back for more! It’s like lunch in Venice beach…
*available with non dairy cheese for the Vegan option
VEEGO The Vegan PIE
$14.00 – $23.00
Detroit Style Pizza | 100% VEGAN | Plant based pizza
Our sauce is crushed whole tomatoes (nothing else added) seasoned to perfection!
*the crust is made from Italian artisan flour that is allowed to ferment 48 hours so it’s easy to digest
‘mozzerella’ is made in house using alternative milk (dairy free)
seitan from scratch is available as a topping
* you can now modify your Veego with fun stuff we make from delicious local vegetables such as charred bell peppers, many magical mushrooms, and / or broccoli rabe.
Square Pie City Desserts
Chocolate Hazelnut Dip Biscotto
$7.00
Housemade Chocolate Praline spread in the cutest jar with a pack of the perfect Italian biscuits to dip! This might just be the best thing ever.
Leave the gun, Take the Cannoli
$8.00 – $12.00
Chocolate Chip – Whipped Ricotta Cannoli (3 mini pieces)
Ricotta cheese filling, chocolate chips, pistachios, and orange peel for this Little Italy classic!
We recommend 2 pieces per person